Paul Ehrlich in the early 1900s sought a “magic bullet” for each disease (including cancer). Given the alternatives at the time, when he found Salvarsan it could be considered a magic bullet against syphilis. Today Dr. Dale Bredesen has replaced “magic” with “silver” and “bullet” with “buckshot.” In his effort to cure Alzheimer’s “Bredesen believed in firing a “silver buckshot” (a reference to the sprayed pellets that come out of shotgun shells) by modifying 36 factors simultaneously” (Gellman, p. 18).
I have not investigated Dr. Bredesen’s “cure” for Alzheimer’s and express no opinion on it. I will express the opinion that I do not like the arrogantly dismissive tone of Lindsay Gellman’sThe New York Times article, bowing to “experts,” but calling Bredesen “Mr.” instead of the “Dr.” he has earned.
And I do like the idea that sometimes what is effective against a disease (including cancer) is not a single drug or therapy, but several taken together. For example, multi-drug cocktails have been effectively used against HIV, childhood leukemia, and Hodgkin’s lymphoma.
Ehrlich’s big dream was to find a magic bullet for each disease. But maybe it is mostly more promising to dream of the magic buckshot.
[N.B., the “Paul Ehrlich” I refer to is not the contemporary environmental alarmist “Paul Ehrlich” who famously lost his bet with the heroic heretic Julian Simon.]
The NYT article quoted above:
(Note: the online version of the NYT article was updated May 31, 2025, and has the title “An Expensive Alzheimer’s Lifestyle Plan Offers False Hope, Experts Say.”)
One thought on “Dream of the Magic Buckshot”